Attorneys fail kids on imprisonment

Artwork by Chips Mackinolty, long regarded as one of Australia’s most accomplished political poster artists. A one-hour interview with Chips about his extraordinary life and work has recently been posted online at Episode #6 – Chips Mackinolty – A LIMINAL SPACE

‘Right now in every state and territory children as young as 10 years old can be arrested by police, hauled before a court and sent to youth prisons’. Raise the Age

No child belongs in prison. That’s why the ‘Keep Kids in the Community’ coalition was calling on governments to raise the age of criminal responsibility from 10 to 14 years, bringing us into line with other countries. For example, the European average is 14 years.

All the medical evidence tells us that childrens’ brains are still developing at this age, and early contact with the criminal legal system can cause lifelong harm. Many of these children suffer from cognitive impairment, which has many causes including the foetal alcohol syndrome.

Other reasons cited for this change are protection of children’s rights and the limited ability of doli incapax (of 10-14 year olds not knowing their behaviour is wrong rather than just being mischievous). In 1998 the Australian Government abolished the principle of doli incapax.

The Council of Attorneys-General, consisting of lawmakers from states, territories and the Commonwealth, had agreed in 2018 it would be appropriate to consider raising the age from 10 to 14 years. However, in late July 2020, when they met again to discuss the issue, they voted to delay for another year a decision on raising the age of criminal responsibility.

According to the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare there were almost 600 children aged 10 to 13 in detention in Australia last financial year. More than 60 per cent were Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander children.

NSW Attorney-General  Mark Speakman said (SMH July 27, 2020) that in NSW there were currently 200 young people in youth justice centres, down by a third from five years ago. The youngest offenders in the NSW corrections system were three offenders who are aged 13 with no-one aged between 10 to 12 in youth justice.

He expected a decision, one way or another, next year: “Community safety is the most important criteria in all of this… [it] doesn’t necessarily mean though locking people up; there is a considerable amount of evidence that the best way to treat young offenders is therapeutically to avoid reoffending.”

Reasons for delay include the need to develop therapeutic strategies, social support and educational programs to facilitate the proposed change. One can only hope these issues will be addressed before the next meeting of the Council of Attorneys-General in 2021. Meanwhile, community pressure and campaigns need to keep going.

Share thisShare on FacebookShare on LinkedInTweet about this on TwitterEmail to someone